Craving the bold, mouthwatering flavors that define New York City? From iconic delis to hidden neighborhood gems, New York sandwiches are more than just food—they’re a cultural experience. Whether you’re a local or planning your first NYC best food tour, here are 9 must-try New York sandwiches that will leave you wanting more.
Table of Contents
Top 9 New York Sandwiches
1. The Classic NYC Pastrami on Rye
No list of New York sandwiches is complete without the legendary pastrami on rye. Served hot with juicy, peppery pastrami, tangy mustard, and fresh rye bread, this sandwich is an NYC deli staple. Katz’s Delicatessen is the go-to spot, offering generous slices of perfectly seasoned meat stacked high. The balance of savory, slightly spicy pastrami with the earthy rye bread is a taste of history in every bite.
The pastrami on rye represents the heart of NYC’s deli culture, blending Eastern European traditions with New York flair. Its rich flavors and satisfying texture make it a must-try for anyone exploring the city’s culinary landscape.
2. The Iconic Bagel & Lox Sandwich
A true New York breakfast classic, the bagel and lox sandwich features a fresh, chewy bagel layered with silky smoked salmon, cream cheese, capers, onions, and tomatoes. Head to Russ & Daughters for an authentic experience that captures the essence of New York sandwiches with every bite. The salty, creamy, and slightly tangy combination is a flavor explosion that defines NYC mornings.
The bagel and lox is not just a sandwich; it’s an institution. Its roots in the city’s Jewish immigrant communities reflect New York’s rich cultural tapestry, making it a beloved favorite among locals and tourists alike.Try different bagel varieties like sesame, poppy, or everything to add a new twist to this classic.
3. The Legendary Chopped Cheese of Harlem
Born in the bodegas of Harlem, the chopped cheese sandwich is NYC’s answer to the cheeseburger. Ground beef, onions, melted cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo are chopped together on the griddle, then piled into a hero roll. Blue Sky Deli (aka Hajji’s) is the iconic spot to grab this savory delight. Its hearty, greasy goodness is perfect for a late-night bite or a quick lunch on the go.
The chopped cheese is a symbol of NYC street food culture. Affordable, delicious, and filling, it embodies the spirit of the city—diverse, bold, and unapologetically authentic.
4. The Italian Hero from Faicco’s
Layered with Italian cold cuts like salami, capicola, and mortadella, topped with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and a drizzle of olive oil and vinegar, the Italian hero is a flavor-packed masterpiece. Faicco’s Italian Specialties in the West Village serves one of the best New York sandwiches, combining fresh ingredients with traditional Italian flavors.
The Italian hero is more than just a sandwich—it’s a celebration of NYC’s Italian-American heritage. The blend of savory meats, sharp cheese, and tangy dressing creates a complex yet harmonious flavor profile that’s hard to resist.
Add hot peppers, roasted red peppers, or a splash of balsamic glaze to enhance the flavors even more.
5. The Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
A beloved staple in NYC’s Italian-American communities, the eggplant parm hero is made with crispy, breaded eggplant slices, rich marinara sauce, and gooey melted mozzarella, all tucked into a crusty Italian roll. Try Parm in Little Italy for a modern twist on this classic New York sandwich. The combination of crunchy eggplant and creamy cheese is comfort food at its finest.
Its rich, comforting flavors and satisfying texture make the eggplant parm hero a standout. The crispy eggplant holds up beautifully against the tangy sauce and melty cheese, creating a sandwich that’s both hearty and flavorful.
This sandwich proves that you don’t need meat to enjoy one of the best New York sandwiches. Add fresh basil or a sprinkle of Parmesan for an extra flavor kick.
6. The Roast Beef with Mozzarella from Defonte’s
Defonte’s in Red Hook is famous for its roast beef sandwich, featuring thinly sliced roast beef, fresh mozzarella, and a touch of gravy on a sesame hero roll. The combination of tender meat, creamy cheese, and savory juices makes it a standout among New York sandwiches. The addition of pickled vegetables adds a tangy crunch that balances the richness of the beef.
This sandwich is a testament to simplicity done right. The quality of the ingredients shines through, making every bite a perfect balance of flavors and textures. Pair this sandwich with a side of crispy fries or a tangy coleslaw to complete your meal.
7. The Reuben Sandwich
Packed with corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing, the Reuben is a hearty, flavorful sandwich that’s beloved across NYC. The Carnegie Deli may be gone, but you can still find incredible Reubens at places like 2nd Ave Deli and Sarge’s Deli. The tangy sauerkraut and creamy dressing complement the savory corned beef perfectly.
The Reuben’s bold flavors and satisfying crunch make it a favorite among sandwich lovers. Its combination of salty, tangy, and creamy elements creates a flavor explosion that’s hard to beat.
8. The Banh Mi from Saigon Sandwich
While not traditionally New York-born, the Vietnamese banh mi has found a special place in the city’s diverse food scene. Featuring crisp baguettes filled with savory pork, pickled vegetables, cilantro, and spicy mayo, Saigon Sandwich in Chinatown serves one of the city’s best New York sandwiches. The contrast of crunchy bread, tender meat, and tangy veggies is irresistible.
The banh mi showcases NYC’s global culinary influence. Its vibrant flavors and unique textures make it a refreshing alternative to traditional deli sandwiches. Experiment with different proteins like lemongrass chicken, tofu, or grilled shrimp to experience new flavor profiles.
9. The Cubano from Cafe Habana
This Cuban-inspired sandwich is packed with roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard, all pressed to perfection on Cuban bread. Cafe Habana in Nolita delivers a Cubano that’s crispy, juicy, and full of bold flavors—a must-try in the world of New York sandwiches. The Cubano’s perfect balance of savory, tangy, and crunchy elements makes it a standout. Its vibrant flavors and satisfying texture have earned it a devoted following in NYC. Ask for extra pickles and mustard if you love bold, tangy flavors.
Final Bite
New York City is a sandwich lover’s paradise, offering everything from traditional deli favorites to international street food sensations. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pastrami on rye or an adventurous banh mi, these 9 best New York sandwiches are sure to satisfy your cravings.
What Makes New York Sandwiches So Special?
It’s not just the ingredients; it’s the culture, history, and diversity behind every bite. NYC’s sandwich scene reflects the city’s melting pot of cultures, offering flavors from around the world. Each sandwich tells a story, from the immigrant roots of the Italian hero to the street-smart origins of the chopped cheese.
Where to Find the Best NYC Sandwiches
- Katz’s Delicatessen for classic pastrami
- Russ & Daughters for bagel & lox
- Blue Sky Deli for chopped cheese
- Faicco’s for Italian heroes
- Parm for eggplant parm heroes
- Defonte’s for roast beef with mozzarella
- 2nd Ave Deli for Reubens
- Saigon Sandwich for banh mi
- Cafe Habana for Cubanos
Which sandwich will you try first? Let us know in the comments! Share your own favorites and hidden sandwich gems across NYC—because when it comes to the best New York sandwiches, there’s always more to discover!