Slicing Through the Windy City: Top 7 Must-Try Pizza Places in Chicago for Foodies

Photo of author
Written By Bianca

The Passionate Traveler and Creator of Travelyas

Welcome to Chicago, where the skyline meets the clouds and culinary dreams come alive! The city isn’t just known for its towering skyscrapers and rich culture—it’s a pizza lover’s paradise. From the iconic deep-dish oozing with cheese to thin-crust creations bursting with flavor, Chicago offers the best pizza for every palate. Join us on a tasty journey to explore the top 7 must-try pizza spots, each serving up unique pizza creations that are sure to wow any foodie. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, discover why these pizzerias are the ultimate destinations for the best pizza in Chicago!

Chicago’s Pizza Scene

When it comes to pizza, few cities can rival the culinary prowess of Chicago. This city is a mecca for foodies craving delicious slices that are as diverse as its vibrant culture. With a rich history and an unmistakable passion for pie, Chicago’s pizza scene offers something special for every palate—whether you’re a die-hard deep-dish devotee or a thin-crust enthusiast. Chicago’s love affair with pizza dates back over a century, and today, it’s home to some of the most iconic pizzerias in the world.

But what makes this city’s offerings stand out? From savory toppings piled high to cheesy layers oozing from golden crusts, there’s no shortage of creativity here. Whether you’re in search of the best pizza in Chicago or eager to try a unique pizza, buckle up your taste buds because we’re about to embark on a mouthwatering journey through seven must-try pizza places that capture the essence of “the best pizza in Chicago.” Get ready to slice through the Windy City!

What Makes Chicago Pizza Unique?

Chicago pizza, known as the best pizza in Chicago, is famous for its unique deep-dish style. With a thick, pie-like crust, it forms a sturdy base for a flavorful combination of cheese, meats, veggies, and chunky tomato sauce.

The layering technique keeps the ingredients perfectly balanced, while the blend of spices adds rich depth to every bite. Chicago’s pizza scene is also diverse, offering variations like stuffed pizzas and tavern-style thin crusts, each with its own twist. This variety and creativity make indulging in Chicago pizza a truly unforgettable experience.

Top 7 Must-Try Pizza Places:

When it comes to pizza, Chicago has perfected the art. Here are seven iconic spots that every foodie should visit for the best pizza in Chicago, each offering a unique pizza experience. Giordano’s is famous for its stuffed deep-dish pizza. Layers of cheese and toppings create a hearty slice that’s hard to beat, making it a must-try for deep-dish lovers.

Lou Malnati’s takes pride in its buttery crust and fresh ingredients. Their classic sausage pie is a must-try, offering a delicious twist on the traditional Chicago deep-dish. Pequod’s Pizza offers a unique caramelized crust that keeps locals coming back for more. Don’t miss their pan-style offerings, which provide a sweet, savory, and crispy experience.

Gino’s East boasts graffiti-covered walls and legendary deep-dish options that never disappoint. The iconic Chicago pizza spot offers a true taste of the city. Coalfire Pizza stands out with its coal-fired oven producing crispy, charred crusts unlike any other place in the city. The unique method results in a deliciously crispy and flavorful pizza.

Giordano’s

Giordano’s is a cornerstone of Chicago’s pizza scene, often hailed as offering the best pizza in Chicago. Known for its iconic stuffed deep-dish pizza, this eatery has been delighting locals and visitors alike since 1974. The crust is thick yet flaky, providing the perfect vessel for layers of cheese and toppings. Once you slice into it, expect a gooey eruption of mozzarella that hits all the right notes.

You can’t go wrong with their signature dish: the Classic Cheese Stuffed Pizza. It’s simple but incredibly satisfying. For those feeling adventurous, try adding spinach or sausage to elevate your experience further with a unique pizza twist. Each Giordano’s location exudes warmth and hospitality. The ambiance feels welcoming, making it an ideal spot to gather with friends or family over delicious slices. Whether you’re dining in or opting for takeout, savor every bite knowing you’re indulging in one of the best pizzas in Chicago.

Lou Malnati’s

Lou Malnati’s is a Chicago institution that has perfected the art of deep-dish pizza. Founded in 1971, it embodies the spirit of Windy City dining with its buttery crust and generous toppings, making it one of the best pizza in Chicago spots to visit. The crust is where the magic begins. It’s flaky and rich, cradling layers of gooey mozzarella cheese sourced from Wisconsin. Fresh tomatoes add a burst of flavor to every bite, creating an irresistible combination.

One standout option is their signature Lou Malnati’s Special Pizza. Packed with sausage made from a family recipe, it showcases how tradition meets taste in each slice, making it a unique pizza experience. Don’t forget about their famous garlic butter topping—it’s pure bliss for your palate. Whether you choose to dine in or take out, expect friendly service that makes you feel right at home amidst the bustling atmosphere. For any foodie searching for the best pizza in Chicago, this spot should be on your radar.

Pequod’s Pizza

Pequod’s Pizza is a must-visit for those craving an unforgettable slice. Nestled in Lincoln Park and Morton Grove, this local gem has carved out a distinct identity within Chicago’s pizza scene, earning a reputation for being one of the best pizza spots in the city.

What sets Pequod’s apart is its legendary caramelized crust. This unique cooking method allows the cheese to crisp against the sides of the deep-dish pan, creating a delightful texture that crunches with every bite. It’s a true standout in the world of unique pizza.

The rich sauce boasts robust flavors, perfectly complemented by fresh toppings. Whether you prefer classic pepperoni or adventurous combinations like spinach and feta, there’s something for everyone here.

Be prepared for a cozy atmosphere filled with pizza-loving patrons. It’s not just about eating; it’s about experiencing artisan craftsmanship in each dish served hot from the oven. Don’t miss this essential stop on your quest for the best pizza in Chicago!

Art of Pizza

Art of Pizza is a hidden gem for those craving a slice of something special. Located in the heart of Chicago, this spot combines traditional Italian recipes with innovative flavors. The menu features both stuffed and thin-crust options, catering to every pizza lover’s preference. Their signature pie comes loaded with fresh toppings and rich cheese that melts beautifully.

One standout is their pesto chicken pizza—a delightful twist that will excite your taste buds. Pair it with one of their homemade salads for a perfect meal. The laid-back atmosphere makes it an ideal place to relax after exploring the city. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, Art of Pizza never disappoints. Don’t forget to ask about daily specials; they often feature seasonal ingredients that elevate each bite.

Piece Brewery and Pizzeria

Piece Brewery and Pizzeria stands out in the Chicago pizza scene, blending craft beer with mouthwatering pies. Located in Wicker Park, this spot offers a laid-back vibe perfect for foodies. If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Chicago, this is a must-visit. The menu features a variety of styles, but their standout is undoubtedly the New Haven-style thin crust. It’s crispy yet pliable, allowing you to fold each slice effortlessly as you savor every bite.

Don’t miss their signature “Green Monster,” loaded with fresh basil pesto and mozzarella. Pair it with one of their house-brewed beers for an unforgettable meal. With unique pizza options and an atmosphere that buzzes with energy, it’s an ideal place to hang out after exploring the city. With its commitment to quality ingredients and innovative recipes, Piece Brewery truly embodies what makes Chicago pizza exceptional.

Gino’s East

Gino’s East is a staple in Chicago’s vibrant pizza scene. Founded in 1966, it quickly gained popularity for its signature deep-dish style, making it one of the best pizza spots in Chicago. What sets Gino’s apart? The golden, flaky crust infused with just the right amount of cornmeal creates a texture that’s both crisp and buttery. When you take your first bite, you’ll taste layers of gooey mozzarella cheese topped with fresh tomatoes and savory sausage. It’s a unique pizza experience that’s hard to beat.

The atmosphere here is equally inviting. Walls adorned with graffiti give it character and showcase the love locals have for this beloved establishment. Pair your pizza with one of their craft beers for an authentic Chicago experience. If deep dish isn’t your thing, they also serve thin-crust options that are equally delicious. Whether you’re a tourist or a lifelong resident, Gino’s East is definitely among the best pizza in Chicago to satisfy any craving.

Coalfire Pizza

Coalfire Pizza is where tradition meets innovation. This pizzeria stands out with its unique coal-fired ovens, which impart a distinct flavor to every pie, making it a top contender for the best pizza in Chicago. The crust here is thin and crispy, offering the perfect base for an array of toppings. You can choose from classic combinations or indulge in something daring, like their signature “Hot Italian” loaded with spicy sausage and roasted red peppers.

Don’t overlook their white pizzas either. The garlic ricotta blend adds a creamy touch that balances beautifully with fresh veggies. For those who appreciate craft beer, Coalfire offers an impressive selection on tap. Pair your pizza with a local brew for the ultimate experience. The ambiance feels cozy yet vibrant—ideal for both casual dinners and special gatherings. Whether you’re a Chicago native or just visiting, this spot deserves a place on your list of must-tries when seeking unique pizza and the best pizza in Chicago.

Insider Tips for Ordering and Navigating the Menu

When exploring the best pizza in Chicago, a little strategy can enhance the experience. Start by asking your server for recommendations—locals often know the hidden gems not listed on the menu. If you’re in a group, consider sharing pizzas to sample different styles without overstuffing yourself. Many pizzerias offer unique toppings and crust options, so be adventurous! Adding ingredients like giardiniera or pesto can elevate your slice. For those who don’t want to wait, check out online ordering for pickup and enjoy Chicago’s pizza at your own pace. Keep an eye out for daily specials—they’re a great way to try seasonal flavors at a good value.

Bonus: Hidden Gems for Unique Pizza

For those seeking unique pizza, Chicago has more than just deep-dish. Bartoli’s Pizzeria serves hand-tossed pies with fresh ingredients and a signature white pizza that’s a creamy twist. Labriola Chicago specializes in Neapolitan-style pizzas cooked in a wood-fired oven, offering a perfectly blistered crust with a soft chewiness. Lastly, Dimo’s Pizza redefines pizza with inventive toppings like mac and cheese or vegan options. These spots prove there’s much more to Chicago’s pizza scene, delivering flavors that excite foodies in every bite!

Conclusion: Why Chicago is the Ultimate Destination for Pizza Lovers

Chicago stands out as a pizza lover’s paradise, offering a wide variety of options from deep-dish to thin crust. The best pizza in Chicago combines rich culinary history with local traditions, like iconic Lou Malnati’s or hidden gems such as Coalfire Pizza. Each pizzeria has its own unique pizza style, inviting you to explore flavors and experiences that can’t be found anywhere else. Whether you’re new to Chicago or a local, ask around and try something new for an unforgettable food adventure. With so many options, every slice tells a story of this vibrant city.

Leave a Comment